نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Explaining the existential (ontological) relationship between an action and its recompense—framed as the "embodiment of deeds" (*tajassum-i a‘māl*)—constitutes a challenging topic within the theological and exegetical traditions of both major Islamic schools of thought. This study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of the views held by Islamic exegetes and theologians, seeking to delineate the points of convergence and divergence regarding the nature of this doctrine. Employing a descriptive-analytical methodology and relying on library-based research, this study categorizes existing perspectives into two broad theoretical frameworks: first, the view positing the "identity of the deed and the recompense," which—grounded in both rational/philosophical (*ḥikmī*) and scriptural (*naqlī*) foundations—asserts that rewards and punishments are the otherworldly manifestations of the very actions performed in this world; and second, the view interpreting "embodiment as testimony," which regards this phenomenon merely as evidence of one’s desert for a specific recompense, while rejecting any causal link between the action itself and the intrinsic nature of the recompense.The research findings indicate that, while both sides agree on the occurrence of *tajassum* (the embodiment of deeds), they diverge in their explanations of how this process unfolds. Specifically, the theory of *‘ayniyyat* (identity/consubstantiality) is articulated through five distinct interpretations—focusing on psychological dispositions, the existential transformation of actions across various realms, causal-generative relationships, and the persistence of matter and energy. In contrast, the "testimony-based" perspective removes *tajassum* from the realm of retribution, imbuing it instead with an informative and revelatory character.
کلیدواژهها English